I made these chai spice sugar cookies over the weekend, they were so good I couldn’t wait to share them. It’s no secret that I love all kinds of tea, or that a chai latte is much more likely to be on my cafe table these days than a coffee.
It’s a little odd then that matcha has made its way into everything from ice cream to smoothies, brownies to bread in my kitchen over the last few months but chai hasn’t made it beyond my teacup. I thought it was time for masala chai, one of my most loved teas of all time to have its moment in the sunshine, or in my mixer at least.
So as I was sitting over my steaming cup of chai and savouring that happy heady aroma of spices that wafted from it, I started envisaging the perfect chai-spiced cookie to sit alongside my daily cuppa.
I had to be something not too rich. I didn’t want it to compete with my perfectly steeped brew but it should be tasty and a little naughty all the same. Chai spices are enticing and dredge up a lifetime of warming memories.
While I happily drink it all year round it’s a flavour and scent that is especially suited to family celebrations like Easter and Christmas. A little jar of homemade chai tea spices or a pretty wrapped pack of these cookies would always be a welcome gift to have on hand during the holidays.
It’s also a versatile drink, while a dash of milk is traditional and a froth of milk and sweetness makes it decadent, it’s equally so perfectly balanced that some days I just love to drink it black and savour its unadulterated delights.
Table of Contents
So what exactly is Chai?
Well honestly in most countries chai or cha just means tea, any sort of tea. So for example my beloved matcha means ‘powdered tea’ or sencha translates to ‘simmered tea’. When chai is mentioned in the west though it usually refers to masala chai, a traditional tea originating in India.
Masala chai involves simmering black tea with milk and a combination of spices. The spices would have varied depending on season, availability and the region but the most common are:
- Cardamom – intensly fragrant, fundamental to a good chai
- Cinnamon – warming and sweet
- Fennel seed – light licorice or anise flavour
- Ginger – a fresh and spicy note
- Black pepper – a hot and spicy kick
- Clove – strong and musky
- Coriander seed – sweet and mild
- Star Anise – sweet licorice flavour
- You can’t substitute baking powder for the baking soda and cream of tartar. The combination of the baking soda and cream of tartar working together will ensure the best rise giving the cookies the right soft and chewy texture. Substituting will likely result in flat crispy biscuits … *sigh* … you can tell I’ve tried this in the past can’t you? While baking powder and soda are both rising agents they work quite differently , it’s like trying to make bread and replacing the yeast with another rising agent, it doesn’t work.
- Doubling down on the chai spices, is it necessary? Possibly not but the milky long brewed chai in addition to the ground spices results in an unmatched depth of flavour that is well worth the tiny bit of extra effort. Really.
- Mix your sugar spice mix for coating in a shallow bowl, it makes it easier to cover the balls of cookie batter without coating your kitchen in the mix too.
- Don’t skip the step of leaving the cookies on the hot tray to cool a little before moving to a cooling rack. These are buttery, rich and chewy cookies and those tempting crackles will open up and break if you try to move them straight out of the oven.
If you enjoyed this recipe please consider saving it to Pinterest. It helps us, and it helps others search for inspiration in the kitchen.